How the Language of “Microaggressions” Plays Out in Employment Law – Copy

How the Language of “Microaggressions” Plays Out in Employment Law – Copy

By Ella Zalon (7/28/2023)

Commonly experienced in workplace settings, microaggressions are comments or behaviors made due to underlying biases held towards certain groups. They point to an implicit attitude one may hold about a protected class (e.g., ethnic, racial, gender minorities) and can be overlooked or unnoticed by bystanders. Microaggressions may not be direct remarks made about a protected class but rather about perceived characteristics associated with the group. Workplace policies and practices that disallow certain hairstyles more commonly worn by certain racial groups are an example of microaggressions that have been covered by the media in recent years. 

Though subtle or indirect, microaggressions can be damaging and have the potential to create a hostile work environment. More recently, the term has begun to appear in some courtrooms. Theoretically, if deemed pervasive enough, microaggressions could give rise to liability under Title VII (a federal law that protects employees from discrimination). Though there are little to no cases that hinge entirely on arguments around microaggressions, looking at some decisions in which the term is discussed can indicate how the use of this language plays out in court. 

Most microaggressions aren’t the product of open hostility — they come from unconscious bias, the automatic stereotypes and assumptions people form outside their own awareness. That distinction matters for how a workplace responds, but it doesn’t change the legal analysis: California law looks at the impact of the conduct on a protected employee, not whether the person responsible meant any harm.

What Is a Microaggression?

The term “microaggression” was coined in the 1970s by Harvard psychiatrist Dr. Chester M. Pierce to describe the everyday, often subtle put-downs experienced by Black Americans. Psychologist Dr. Derald Wing Sue later expanded the concept into three recognized categories:

  • Microassaults — conscious, deliberate remarks or actions meant to demean (e.g., using a racial slur or deliberately excluding someone from a meeting).
  • Microinsults — comments that unintentionally convey rudeness or insensitivity toward a person’s identity (e.g., telling a colleague of color they’re “surprisingly articulate”).
  • Microinvalidations — comments that dismiss or negate a person’s lived experience (e.g., telling an employee who raises a bias concern that they’re “overreacting.”)

While a single microaggression rarely amounts to unlawful harassment on its own, a documented pattern — especially when tied to a protected characteristic — can support a hostile work environment or discrimination claim under both federal and California law.

When Microaggressions Don’t Hold Up in Court

There does not seem to be a clear consensus as to whether microaggressions can be considered sufficient evidence in court. 

In Chen v. Yellen (2021), a federal lawsuit in Illinois, a judge found that Plaintiff Fiona Chen did not sufficiently prove she was experiencing harassing behaviors or a hostile work environment. Arguments that the treatment Chen experienced were a result of her protected classes were deemed “speculative.” Chen implored the courts to consider other cases involving microaggressions, to which the court responded: “Regardless of whether an aggression is micro or macro, the Court considers the evidence of hostility in totality.” What can be surmised here is that the court is willing to consider microaggressions as part of the evidence, insofar as they are severe or pervasive enough to contribute to an overall picture of discriminatory behavior. It must be clear how something claimed as a microaggression could be construed as discriminatory. Importantly, a clear pattern of mistreatment and discriminatory behavior must be identified whether it arises from micro or macro aggressions.

On the other hand, courts have also held that microaggressions cannot be considered sufficient evidence of discriminatory treatment on their own. In Chambers v. City of Lakeland (2022), Plaintiff was a patrol officer claiming differential treatment and assignments from her male peers. The court asked her to specify and explain the microaggressions that she alleged she experienced. The judge concluded that the few instances of comments directed at Plaintiff, including comments that she was “always crying” “because she is sensitive” and the remarks “why do you wear your hair in a bun” and “do you even brush your hair,” were not pervasive and were not sufficient evidence of a hostile work environment on their own. Citing Weinberg v. William Blair & Co., LLC (2015), the court stated that “microaggressions are more similar to ‘mere offensive utterances’ than ‘physically threatening or humiliating statements,’ and are insufficient to support a hostile work environment claim.” 

In many cases where the employee-plaintiffs were unsuccessful, they failed to provide sufficient evidence of frequent or numerous microaggressions and did not provide specific descriptions of said microaggressions. On top of this, the term itself does not seem unanimously understood. For a microaggression-based claim to be successful, evidence must fulfill already established criteria for what legally entails a hostile or discriminatory workplace. 

How Can Language Around Microaggressions be Successfully Utilized in a Courtroom?

Employees can protect themselves by calling out discrimination early on and being specific about what they are experiencing. In some cases, employees have successfully pleaded cases that included specific, concrete allegations of microaggressions tied to adverse employment consequences.

In Pringle v. Wheeler (2020), a judge denied Defendant’s motion to dismiss the case. Plaintiff alleged both discriminatory and retaliatory behavior at his workplace over a long period of time. He engaged in protected activity when reporting to his employer that he felt he was being discriminated against based on his race. Before and after this report, he experienced differential treatment, including being denied opportunities and being disproportionately scrutinized in comparison to his peers. The judge found that Pringle provided sufficient evidence of a hostile work environment, due to a pattern of differential treatment that altered his ability to do his job. The judge writes, “While macroaggressions undoubtedly constitute a hostile work environment, pervasive microaggressions have the ability to diminish the workplace significantly as well. Put differently, a severe episode that occurs as rarely as once violates Title VII, and so does a relentless pattern of lesser harassment that extends over a long period of time.” In Pringle v. Wheeler, Plaintiff successfully presented a persistent pattern of differential treatment over an extended period that affected his work duties and performance. The judge legitimizes “lesser” forms of harassment as constituting a hostile environment, so long as the incidents presents as a pattern and clearly affect one’s ability to do their job. 

References to and documentation of specific comments that can be construed as microaggressions can be crucial in a successful argument in court. In De Souza v. Planned Parenthood Federation of America (2022), Defendant’s motion to dismiss the case was denied by the court. An array of specific comments targeting Plaintiff’s religion were presented as evidence to the court. A supervisor told Plaintiff that she “does not want an old Jewish woman running a multicultural department” (Plaintiff is a Jewish woman) and described Jewish women as “birthing factories,” among other remarks. Plaintiff brought up concerns about “microaggressions” towards Jewish people in emails to her supervisor and was terminated soon thereafter. The dispute at hand during the motion to dismiss stage of the case was about the retaliation claims. The judge found that Plaintiff’s emails about microaggressions towards Jewish people at work could be deemed protected activity. It is significant that the court concluded that complaining about microaggressions specifically can be deemed protected activity because it legitimizes the notion that microaggressions can manifest discrimination. 

In both of these cases, employees asserted retaliation claims because they brought their concerns about microaggressions to the attention of their workplaces and they suffered adverse employment actions afterwards.

California Employees Have Stronger Protections Than Title VII Alone

The cases discussed above were decided under Title VII, but Valerian Law clients are also protected by California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), which is broader than its federal counterpart. Following the California Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Bailey v. San Francisco District Attorney’s Office, 16 Cal. 5th 611 (2024), even a single sufficiently severe remark — including a racial slur — can be enough to support a hostile work environment claim.

In Bailey, a Black employee alleged a coworker used a racial slur in a single conversation. The California Supreme Court held that under the “totality of the circumstances” standard, one severe incident can meet FEHA’s threshold, rejecting the argument that harassment must be repeated to be actionable.

For California employees, this means the federal-law bar set by Chen v. Yellen and Chambers v. City of Lakeland is not the whole picture. Under FEHA, a well-documented pattern of microaggressions — or even one severe incident — may carry real legal weight.

Common Examples of Microaggressions in the Workplace

Microaggressions can target any protected characteristic. Common examples include:

  • Race and ethnicity: “Where are you really from?” or praising someone as “well-spoken” in a tone that implies surprise.
  • Gender: Assuming a woman in a leadership role is “aggressive” or “emotional” for behavior praised in male colleagues.
  • Disability: Questioning whether a disability accommodation is “really necessary,” or excluding an employee from projects based on unspoken assumptions about their ability.
  • LGBTQ+ identity: Asking a new coworker if they have a “husband or wife” rather than a “partner,” or repeatedly misgendering a colleague after being corrected.
  • Age: Referring to older employees as “out of touch,” or steering younger employees away from client-facing roles based on assumptions about experience.

Religion: Scheduling mandatory events during religious holidays without accommodation, or commenting on an employee’s religious dress or practices.

What to Do If You’re Experiencing Microaggressions at Work

  1. Document everything. Keep a written record of each incident — date, time, what was said or done, who was present, and how it affected your work.
  2. Identify the pattern. Courts look at frequency and severity together, so a log showing a consistent pattern strengthens a potential claim.
  3. Report it internally, in writing, when possible. As Pringle v. Wheeler and De Souza v. Planned Parenthood show, reporting can itself be protected activity — meaning retaliation for raising the issue is separately unlawful.
  4. Don’t wait for something “big enough.” Under Bailey, even one severe incident can matter — a comment doesn’t need to repeat before it’s worth addressing.

Talk to an employment attorney early. An attorney can help you understand whether what you’re experiencing may support a legal claim and how to protect yourself from retaliation going forward.

FAQs

 Can a single microaggression lead to a lawsuit?

Generally, no — but California law is more favorable to employees than federal law. Under FEHA, following the 2024 Bailey v. San Francisco District Attorney’s Office decision, a single sufficiently severe incident (such as a racial slur) can support a hostile work environment claim. Under Title VII, courts have generally required a pattern of pervasive conduct.

What’s the difference between a microaggression and illegal workplace harassment?

A microaggression becomes potentially unlawful harassment when it is tied to a protected characteristic (like race, gender, disability, or religion) and is either severe enough on its own or part of a pervasive pattern that alters the conditions of your employment.

Can I get fired for reporting microaggressions at work?

No. Reporting concerns about microaggressions or discriminatory language, even informally, can be considered protected activity. If your employer retaliates against you for raising these concerns, you may have a separate legal claim for retaliation.

What should I document if I experience a microaggression at work?

Record the date, time, location, exactly what was said or done, who witnessed it, and how it affected your ability to do your job. Save related emails, messages, or performance reviews that provide context.

Does it matter if the person didn’t mean to be offensive?

Not necessarily. Courts generally evaluate harassment based on its effect on the employee and whether it was tied to a protected characteristic — not solely the speaker’s intent. Unintentional comments can still contribute to a hostile work environment claim.

Do I need a lawyer to address microaggressions at work?

You don’t need a lawyer to report a concern to HR, but consulting an employment attorney early can help you understand your rights, properly document your experience, and protect yourself from retaliation before a situation escalates.

Takeaways about Microaggressions Within Employment Claims

Subtlety and indirectness are inherent to microaggression, which makes microaggressions difficult to rely on as the primary evidence in employment cases. Frequency and severity of microaggressions are crucial to persuading courts to accept microaggressions as forms of discrimination.

Anti-retaliation protections exist for employees who experience discriminatory microaggressions. Calling something out as a microaggression at work can be considered protected activity, and the very act of calling it out early on can contribute to success in court. If you believe you’ve experienced microaggressions within your workplace and want to understand your employee rights, contact our experienced attorneys at Valerian Law PC to discuss the subtleties of such claims and explore potential legal avenues for protection.

© 2026 Valerian Law, P.C. | Powered by Valerian Law, P.C.

Attorney Advertising. Past results and testimonials do not guarantee a similar outcome in a future case.